Despite mounting concerns from pension savers, shareholders of three of the biggest US tech companies that form a significant portion of the ‘Magnificent Seven’ have dismissed calls to address the risks associated with Artificial Intelligence (AI) developments. This, according to an update from UK’s PensionBee.
The news follows previous research by PensionBee, an online pension provider, “that indicated that approximately 10% of defined contribution pension savers’ funds in the UK are invested in the US tech giants, collectively known as the ‘Magnificent Seven’, which includes Amazon, Meta (the parent company of Facebook), and Alphabet (the parent company of Google).”
A recent survey of PensionBee customers1 revealed “that nearly three-quarters (72%) believe shareholders should leverage their voting rights to influence how tech companies utilize AI.”
This strong sentiment reflects a growing apprehension “among pension savers regarding the ethical and operational implications of AI.”
Previous findings also showed significant “support from pension savers for shareholder resolutions at Amazon, Meta (Facebook), and Alphabet (Google) annual general meetings (AGMs).”
However, these resolutions ultimately “failed to pass, underscoring a disconnect between shareholder actions and pension savers’ concerns.”
The results of the related shareholder resolutions at each AGM were as follows:
- Amazon: During Amazon’s AGM, a shareholder resolution was introduced urging Amazon’s Board to establish a committee of independent directors to address AI-associated risks. Further research by PensionBee showed that almost half (45%) of their customers supported this resolution. Unfortunately, it garnered only 10% of the vote.
- Meta (Facebook) & Alphabet (Google): Meta and Alphabet’s AGMs included a shareholder resolution requesting the Board to issue a report assessing the risks associated with generative Artificial Intelligence (gAI) and proposing remedial measures. This resolution was supported by 68% of PensionBee customers surveyed. Despite this backing, the resolution received only 17% of the vote at Meta’s AGM and 18% at Alphabet’s AGM.
- Alphabet (Google): At Alphabet’s AGM, a shareholder resolution called for an independent third-party Human Rights Impact Assessment of Google’s advertising policies and practices. Despite the apparent support, the resolution failed to pass, receiving only 19% of the vote.
Clare Reilly, Chief Engagement Officer at PensionBee, commented:
“The failure of these resolutions is a disappointment for pension savers who tell us that they are increasingly concerned about the ethical implications of AI. We see a strong desire among savers for greater accountability and transparency in how AI is developed and deployed by these tech giants. Their management teams have a responsibility to listen to these concerns and take action to mitigate potential risks. The rapid pace at which AI technology is advancing brings with it significant ethical and social considerations, and it’s imperative that these are not overlooked in the pursuit of innovation.”
As noted in the update:
“PensionBee’s research shows that pension savers are not just passive investors; they are keenly aware of the broader impact of their investments and are calling for responsible stewardship from the companies in which they are invested. This is particularly crucial in the tech sector, where the decisions made today about AI could have far-reaching consequences for society.”
