In a letter forwarded to Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Chairman Jay Clayton, a group of Fintech leaders demanded the Commission to increase Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF) from the current $1.07 million max amount to $20 million – a substantial increase to current rules. The demand to increase Reg CF, an iteration of securities crowdfunding that was created by the JOBS Act of 2012, comes at a time when there is pressure for the US to maintain is position as a leader in investment crowdfunding the space. As pointed out by the signatories, both Germany and the UK have increased their crowdfunding threshold to €8 million (USD $9.4 million). The European Commission may move to make this a pan-European threshold with some EU insiders pushing for a higher amount.
The letter was sent under the letterhead of Crowdfund Capital Advisors (CCA), co-founded by Sherwood “Woodie” Neiss and Jason Best. The two founders were vital to the passage of the JOBS Act when President Obama signed the bill into law.
“Each of the parts of the JOBS Act served a niche well except for those companies that liked the idea of crowdfunding from Main Street investors without the costs of a Title IV (Regulation A+ offering). By increasing the maximum an issuer can raise to $20 million under Regulation Crowdfunding, we can now fill this void and allow a broader spectrum of small issuers into the marketplace. With 2 years of history and data under our belt, we can see that the system is working, capital is flowing, jobs are being created and money is being pumped into our economy. Rather than ask for another de minimus increase in the cap, let’s raise it to an amount that will really allow the industry to take off but in the same systematic and transparent way that benefits issuers, investors, and regulators.”
Neiss, in an email to Chair Clayton, said “the United States should not be left behind, but should make the bold move to increase the cap to $20 million.”
[clickToTweet tweet=”‘the United States should not be left behind, but should make the bold move to increase the cap to $20 million’ #RegCF #Crowdfunding” quote=”‘the United States should not be left behind, but should make the bold move to increase the cap to $20 million’ #RegCF #Crowdfunding”]
The SEC has the ability to act and such a move would most likely have the support of much of Congress and most likely the Executive branch. The question is whether, or not, Chair Clayton will be willing to take such a bold move that will clearly support small business and capital formation – a policy area Clayton has consistently said is one of his top leadership priorities.
The letter to Chair Clayton was signed by the following crowdfunding industry leaders:
- Sherwood Neiss – CCA
- Doug Ellenoff – Ellenoff, Grossman & Schole
- Youngro Lee – CEO of NextSeed
- Tyler Gray – COO of Microventures
- James Dowd – Managing Director North Capital
- Kendrick Nguyen, CEO of Republic
- Ryan Feit – CEO of SeedInvest
- Karen Kerrigan – Small Business and Entrepreneurship Council (SBE Council)
- Ron Miller – co-founder of StartEngine
- Nick Tommarello – CEO of Wefunder
The letter is available for download here and is re-published below.
July 19, 2018
The Honorable Jay Clayton
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission 100 F Street, NE
Washington, DC 20549
Dear Chairman Clayton:
We compromise the largest online crowdfunding platforms and industry influencers in the United States. Given the positive early results since 2016 for both entrepreneurs and investors, we believe the time has come to raise the maximum amount an issuer can raise via Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF) from US$1M to US$20M. Please keep in mind that during the 2 years of this new exemption there has been no fraud and very limited regulatory issues.
Since the launch of Regulation Crowdfunding:
- Over 1,000 companies have filed with the SEC to raise money on online platforms that are registered with FINRA to facilitate capital formation.
- Over $137M has been committed to these issuers. 95% ($130.4M) of that capital was funded and invested into 715 companies (68.5% success rate).
- These 715 companies are supporting 4,172 jobs and producing over $249M in revenue.
- Issuers have filed in almost every state in the Union.
- Issuers have been funded in 80 industries (according to Morningstar’s Global Equity Classification Structure).
The cap should be adjusted because:
- There has been zero fraud, competent issuers have been able to raise serious capital from investors that believe in their products or services, and retail investors (for the first time in recent history) have a transparent, systematic way to back companies they believe in.
- Successfully funded companies are supporting and creating valuable jobs and providing substantial economic activity in a broad range of locally important industries all around the United States.
- The initial cap of US$1M was meant to be adjusted. Only once since the launch of Regulation Crowdfunding has this been adjusted and at the time only by $70,000. Such de minimus adjustments do not fully allow meritorious issuers to fully benefit from this new form of online finance nor expand the opportunity for issuers seeking to raise in excess of $1M.
- The current $1M level is now far below what startups and SMEs need for seed stage capital. May 2018 data indicates that the median sized funding round for Angel or Seed stage companies in the US is $2M. This means that even for the smallest funding round the current limits do not allow an issuer to raise their entire round via Regulation Crowdfunding. This dramatically increases costs and time spent on raising capital by US businesses. This reduces the number of American innovators and job creators in the United States.
- While the “funding gap” that Regulation Crowdfunding was meant to address is filling the void. The funding “opportunity” really comes from those small/medium firms that are seeking to raise up to $20M. Raising funds under $20M has become increasingly challenging as Venture Capital/Private Equity has moved upstream over the past decade. Raising the cap will allow issuers that wish to utilize this form of online finance the ability to raise in excess of $1M and tap their local investors without having to deal with the costly, time consuming process of either filing a full prospectus with the SEC or spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on a private offering.
- Many companies forego Regulation Crowdfunding in favor of Reg D, 506(c), because of the low Reg CF limit. This has the effect of reduced disclosure to investors, since Form D provides less information even than Form C. In addition, ordinary investors are cut out of some of the most attractive deals that have already attracted institutional funding, which seems unfair and counter to one of the goals of Reg CF.
- Both the United Kingdom and Germany have adjusted their caps to 8M EUR (US$9.4M). The United States should not be a follower but a leader
In a FINRA live chat with Robert Cook you said, “I continue to worry that retail investors do not have access to as broad a slice of our capital markets as I would like them to have. Said another way, you have private capital and public capital. Retail investors can really only participate in the public capital, and to the extent private capital has become so robust, you’ve shrunk opportunities. That bothers me a bit. If that trend continues, a much more select group is participating in the growth of the economy.”
We believe increasing the caps on Regulation Crowdfunding will address your concerns and invite more retail investors into a systematic, transparent part of the private capital markets that is creating jobs and providing valuable economic stimulus.
We kindly urge you to adjust the maximum amount an issuer may raise to $20M. Sincerely,
Sherwood Neiss, Crowdfund Capital Advisors
Doug Ellenoff, Ellenoff Grossman & Schole
Youngro Lee, CEO NextSeed
Tyler Gray, COO Microventures
James Dowd, Managing Director North Capital
Kendrick Nguyen, CEO Republic
Ryan Feit, CEO SeedInvest
Karen Kerrigan, Small Business and Entrepreneurship Council Ron Miller, CEO StartEngine
Nick Tommarello, CEO Wefunder